Try resyncing even if it isn't connected to a different console.

Xbox one controller wont turn on. As soon as you shut down xbox either by using the controller or pressing button on the xbox, the controller stays on and once off due to time out, it wont turn the xbox back on. This is a quick walk through of the most common hardware fault with all xbox one controllers. After a few seconds, the fan shuts off and the light goes back to solid orange.

How to fix xbox one controller won't turn on? I've tried changing the batteries. Replied on march 24, 2016.

If the controller doesn’t turn on or stays on. Let's shut down the xbox one system completely. It will drain the remaining power on the console.

Wait 10 seconds or more. If an update is interrupted or the firmware is corrupt, the controller may not turn on. Xbox one s controller won’t turn on.

If the controller turns on when both ends are properly. If your controller just died and doesn't turn on anymore, this. Plug the controller in via usb, and use another controller to update firmware using this.

Install the xbox accessories application. Wait for 40 min suites for its components to cool off. After you have confirmed you have a windows 10 system, you can begin the process of recovering the controller.