GEICO is a much cheaper auto insurance company with better financial strength ratings but Allstate does better with consumers.

Is geico cheaper than allstate. The precise discount percentages can vary. 329 rows Allstate. Keep in mind that your premium depends on your driving record car location age and coverage.

One person commented online that they were sure it is the middle-aged good driver with the clean credit report who receives the cheaper rates at Geico compared to the same profile given to Allstate representatives. You may be able to lower Allstates expensive rates if you can stack a few discounts. Allstates premium rate for excellent drivers is 786 where GEICOs is a lower 709.

If price is your main concern Geico may be right for you. Geico typically has the cheapest car insurance among top national providers. Just like there are some people that claim Allstate is cheaper than Geico there are others still who claim Geico is cheaper than Allstate.

Allstate also sees higher customer satisfaction. GEICO even rated higher than State Farm which is the largest insurance provider in the US. Behind USAA which is only available to military families State Farm is the cheapest in the most states.

Geico can keep down their prices by not offering face-to-face interaction with agents. Geico offers the cheapest rates at an average 1102 per year compared to Allstates average 1486 per year. Allstate and GEICO both offer significant discounts for policyholders with perfect driving records.

NerdWallets analysis of insurance rates found Geico is consistently cheaper than Allstate on average. As a general rule teen drivers should choose GEICO before Allstate. Choosing between Geico vs.