This thread is archived.

Does gandalf say you shall not pass or you cannot pass. Does Gandalf say You cannot pass or You shall not pass. You cannot pass he said. The dark fire will not avail you flame of Udûn.

Fire came from its nostrils. Its just commonly quoted as you shall not pass because he says that later. Although technically thats None shall pass but whos keeping track Later used during the Spanish Civil War.

You shall not pass Gandalf drives his staff into the bridge causing a bright flash of blue light to appear. Bilbo didnt kill Gollum just because he wanted to know the way to. This comes right after Gandalf lists his credentials.

No pasarán in this case They wont pass in response to which General Franco later said Hemos pasado meaning We have passed The Spanish phrase became an international anti-fascist slogan. Tolkiens The Fellowship of the Ring from The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Tolkien was being explicit.

The Fellowship of the Ring 2001You Shall Not Pass short versionFor Jerry Sullivan- - - Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976. Certainly for an American audience You shall not pass in a British accent sounds more authoritative. Its just commonly quoted as you shall not pass because he says that later.

The dark fire will not avail you flame of Udûn As the Balrog swings his flaming sword into. He doesn t actually say that in the book. Flaring its nostrils the Balrog steps forward onto the bridge The bridge collapses from under it as it moves towards Gandalf and breaks before the wizards staff.